As I was driving to work yesterday morning, I immersed myself in my usual a.m. routine: a large fountain drink, a rolled-down window, and the relaxing edification of NPR News.
At some point during the broadcast of “All Things Considered,” co-host Steve Inskeep interviewed Thomas Ricks, author of the popular “Fiasco,” which dealt with the conflict in Iraq.
Ricks’ latest book, “The Gamble,” hits upon the notion that Barack Obama is taking a huge risk in asserting that he can have all U.S. forces out of Iraq in the next couple of years. In Ricks’ view, which is buoyed by interviews with numerous high-ranking military and diplomatic personnel, the war may very well be only “half over.” In speaking about the new President and the foreign policy complexities he’s inherited, the author said something that has stuck with me ever since:
[Paraphrasing]: “In the end, I think Iraq will change Barack Obama more than Barack Obama changes Iraq.”
…
In light of Tuesday’s thoughts, this quote has left me thinking about my own life, as well as the world at large.
Not unlike the cohorts upon cohorts of teachers who moved to New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina, President Obama has set out with idealistic and honest intentions of making a difference. He takes considerable umbrage with the culture that has characterized Washington over the past decade, and he wants to act as a sweeping agent of change.
I can relate to President Obama’s feelings of optimism. As an undergraduate Philosophy major who read a steady helping of Locke, Mill, and the like, I fervently believe that people are, at their core, fundamentally good beings. I also believe in the rights and power of the Individual — I am convinced that conviction and determination are enough to allow very small people to do very large things.
In essence, I’ve always sought to live an engaged life, a life in which I, along with other human beings, can have a dramatic effect on the environments and situations around me. When I attended college, I developed the grandest of ambitions. Upon graduating I travelled to Suzhou, People’s Republic of China, where I taught ESL to university students for an entire academic year.
In the fall of 2006, I was offered a full graduate assistantship in Philosophy at the University of Connecticut — essentially an opportunity to get paid for being a student. I savored the impending opportunity, the chance to flex my mental muscles in the ivory tower, to acquire the tools of knowledge that would enable me to lead the life of the meaningful professor.
… I hated what I saw. Professors were stand-offish; students were all “Type A.” Everyone seemed to care solely about his or her research concerns — but not at all about teaching. The environment reminded me of a large, impersonal machine; there were no agents of change to be found anywhere.
After less than a month, I left the 5-year program and went back to the proverbial drawing board.
…
My then-girlfriend had participated in an alternative certification teaching program for 2 years in Philadelphia, the kind of thing that’s perfect for a would-be world-changer. I began to explore the possibilities of teaching public school in a brand new city.
I’d visited New Orleans once before, to run a half-marathon, in 2003. I knew it to be a laid-back kind of city, but the post-Katrina landscape I’d only experienced via national news outlets, presented numerous worries. Philadelphia (where I was living at the time) was my first choice; I also thought Denver would be a sexy pick.
In the end, I was selected to teach middle-school mathematics in Greater New Orleans. While I could have easily declined the option and chosen simply to work an office job or pursue other interests, I decided that the education rebuilding process taking place in the Big Easy was as vivid a change-the-world opportunity as I was ever likely to find.
…
Again, I moved here with the widest of eyes. I conjured Obama-like visions of closing the achievement gap, of giving dozens of low-income children a shot at an exceptional education.
… Again, I found disappointment
…
Teaching is far and away the most difficult endeavor I’ve undertaken in all my 26 years. It’s also the most humbling.
Imagine: A room full of 10-12 children, all between the ages of 13 and 17, who are attending the school at which you teach because they desperately want to reach their “right grade.” And you, a young idealist with a high IQ and little responsibility other than this job, ready, willing, and able to work towards those very ends.
It should be easy, right? Wrong.
Rather than change the world through education, I’ve allowed education to change me. I’m presently more pessimistic, cynical, and emotionally lazy than I’ve ever been; my students, on the other hand, are still behind.
…
President Obama certainly has a full plate in front of him. I, as a supporter, fervently hope that he can substantiate the unparalleled promise of his ascendence and tangibly bring positive change to our world.
Personally speaking, though, I recognize the considerable force with which idealism can often be flattened.
…
We like to believe that we, as absolute and uniquely wired agents, make history what it is.
This may be so… but the events in which we play a part possess an equal power: They remake us, day in and day out.